Tribal Terrian

Peace in Violence

Ananya S. Guha analyses the nuances of Northeast Indian Poetry

To discuss poetry written in Northeast India is an enormity of tasks. Firstly, to share commonalities from the different matrixes and cultures of the region; secondly, to pin point the major themes of the poets writing in different languages invested as they are with stark realities. However, if we posit a reductionist theory of their poetry, discovering only the violence that is prevalent in their poetry and the attendant brutalization of society we will be doing grave injustice to a body of work kneaded by cohesiveness, lyricism and a well ordered world of sanity. To complement this there also exist a group of English poets who share the Romanticism and mythopoeic vision of their vernacular counterparts.

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

These give to these poets a universal coherence, not an inchoate disorderliness, a world view where love matters; love in its many sided dimensions touching on immutable relationships. In many cases the love for the land and the love of intense relationship coalesce into vastness of images. These poets are imagistic, Romanticists; cannot forget their hills and valleys and the intrinsic beauties of their land now sullied and tarnished.

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Northeast Indian poetry has a remarkable whole, and is marked by the kind of tension which generates all great poetry; it may be at one level the poetry of violence, of torpidity and fear but it is also the poetry of searching, soul searching for peace.

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Among the poets who write in English there is the remarkable expression of mythology and folk-tales, whether in the poetry of Robin. S. Ngangom, Desmond. L. Kharmawphlang, Temsula Ao or Mamang Dai. The search for the past is no escapism; it is a hiatus, gripping and painful, between past and present. The myth of Nohkalikai for example pervades the bi-lingual poetry of the poets in Shillong. Even in Robin. S. Ngangom’s poetry there are such typical and mythological allusions- he has been living in Shillong for the last thirty years or so; but is originally of Manipuri descent.

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

There are two distinct categories of English poets in the region; some are domiciled there like Robin. S. Ngangom, Kynpham Sing Nongkynrih, Mamang Dai, Mona Zote, Nini Lungalang, Janica Pariat and Temsula Ao, while others such as: Anjum Hasan Nabina Das, Nitoo Das, Trisha Bora and Aruni Kashyap live outside the region.

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

However, where does one begin in a discussion or poetry in Northeast India written in a wide spectrum of languages: Assamese, Manipuri, Khasi, Kokborok, Bodo etc.? How does one classify them into a genre of poetry, or is there an urgency to do so? Often considered a homogeneous unit, North East India spells ‘notoriety’ of heterogeneity. We have Manipuri poets, writing in the Bengali dominated Barak Valley of Assam, for example.

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Where is the ‘peace’ then we talked about? Is it in the hills, rivers and lakes or in the mountainous terrain of this beautiful part of the country? Landscaping the past and the present is a recurrent theme of these poets; images embedded in the natural landscape, there is quiescence and peace there, an antidote for all ills, suffering and violence.

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Yet fears, ghostly apparitions and shadows are omnipresent. Thangjam Ibopishak the Manipuri poet says:

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

“… Volcano… you cannot erupt

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Volcano, stay asleep…

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Lava remain slumbering…”

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

(“Volcano You Cannot Erupt”)

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Similarly in his trenchant poem “I Want to Be Killed by an Indian Bullet” there is layered irony but also rejection of the ideology of violence.

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

When Mamang Dai breaks into rapturous delight, there is peace in bewilderment:

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

“I hear the bewildered

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

cry of a deer

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

floating on the

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

waves of moonlight.”

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

(“Moonlight”)

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Desmond. L. Kharmawphlang makes the myth of folklore an archetypal and enduring vision:

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

“I became a folktale…

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

I became a proverb…

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

I became a riddle.”

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

(“Last Night I dreamed”)

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Dreams, visions enter the mindscape like haunting motifs and recurrently, obsessively. This is evident in Chandrakanta Murasingh’s ‘ancient’ love narrative: “The Stone Speaks in the Forest”. There is a myth-making capacity in this poem of a “golden deer” and a “broken heart”.

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

In Saratchand Thiyam’s poem: “Sister” there is a frantic plea:

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

“This rain has not yet let up

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Don’t go out yet, sister…

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Haven’t you heard this

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Sound…

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Don’t you go at all.”

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

There is a predominating fear of violence, but at the end of the poem there is restoration of peace and equanimity. So long as ‘sister’ is safe; then there is peace.

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

The celebrated Assamese poet Harekrishna Deka, a former police officer, knows the story of violence and bullets only too well:

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

“… After dipping in

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Blood the nightlong

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

How ruddy the

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Morning she would

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Be.”

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

(“Dawning”)

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Yet, Kynpham. S. Nongkynrih who predominantly writes in English can envision the prophylactic of love in the midst of ethnic conflict:

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

“Beloved Sundori,

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Yesterday one of my people

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Killed one of your people…

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Through a fearful breeze

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Please let your window open...”

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

(“Sundori”)

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

When Temsula Ao speaks lyrically in her poem: “Stone-People From Lungterok” there is an animated discovery and re-definition of the past. Past is history:

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

“Lungterok, The six stones

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Where the progenitors

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

And forebears

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Of the stone-people

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Were born

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Out of the womb

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Of the earth.”

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Poetry written in Northeast India can be analysed against the backdrop of ethnic violence and militancy/militarism, but it transcends such immediacy into an ideal world bereft of suffering:

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

“… When you leave

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Your native hills

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

I can only speak

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

of lost times,

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

and of sorrow and blood.”

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

(“When You Do Not Return”)

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

These “lost times” are the halcyon days of past. They are juxtaposed with “sorrow and blood” in almost a violent and forceful imagery. But the ‘lost times’ bring peace to the mind as a token of immutable love.

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

The Northeast Indian poets have an ambivalence, towards militarism, love for the land, ethnicity etc. but these are transcended into love: love for woman, love for the hills, ravines and deep gorges, precipitated by gushing waterfalls; in short love for the land. They are able to transmute the chaotic into the subliminal. That is, in the final analysis, the poetry of peace; out of disorderliness, an orderliness. Politics and love complement each other with lyrical utterances. The public and private voices mingle into rhapsody:

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

“You are very pretty,

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Barak river!

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

… Barak river; when

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

your waters soothe

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

the fiery heat,

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

the desert smiles

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

quietly.”

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

(“Barak River You Are Beautiful”, Ilabanta Yumnam)

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

Disquiet transmuted into quiet. Beatific

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

(All references in this article are to Dancing Earth; Penguin Books, New Delhi, 2009)

\r\n

\\r\\n

\r\n

 


Ananya.S. Guha45 Posts

used to work with the Indira Gandhi National Open University, Shillong (Meghalaya) as an Academic Administrator. He has over 30 years of teaching and administrative experience. He has six collections of poetry and his forms have been published world wide. Some of his poems are due to appear soon in an Anthology of Indian Poetry in English to be published by Harper Collins.

Sunset Years

ANANYA S GUHA sums up the discussion on “Old Age Homes” at the recently held Shillong CALM Festival 2013

Sun, 19 May 2013

The Calm of the CALM Festival

Picturesque Shillong gears up to celebrate creativity in the arts, music and literature writes Ananya S Guha

Mon, 22 Apr 2013

Fiction Online

Ananya S Guha writes about the eFiction Magazine, a literary online journal which blends tradition with modernity

Mon, 25 Mar 2013

Peace in Violence

Ananya S. Guha analyses the nuances of Northeast Indian Poetry

Tue, 28 Feb 2012

All for Land

The struggle for land seems to be the crux of all conflict in the region, writes Ananya S Guha

Wed, 01 Aug 2012

One Sohra Summer

Iadalang Pyngrope's book is a delightful blend of history and fiction writes ANANYA S GUHA

Tue, 20 May 2014

Poetry of Darius Cooper

ANANYA S GUHA traverses multiplicity of worlds in the poems of Darius Cooper

Wed, 07 May 2014

Mosaic

Iadalang Pyngrope's poems are experiential totality writes ANANYA S GUHA

Mon, 10 Mar 2014

Fable of the region

PETER W INGTY's book is a interesting exposition of certain historical truths writes ANANYA S GUHA

Fri, 17 Jan 2014

Tea Motif

NINA HARKNESS's novel straddles three decades in tea estates writes ANANYA S GUHA

Thu, 09 Jan 2014

Honour for Temsula Ao

ANANYA S GUHA chats with Sahitya Akademi award winning writer TEMSULA AO

Sun, 22 Dec 2013

Media Matters

ANANYA S GUHA ponders over the role of media in India

Mon, 14 Jul 2014

Rewriting history

ANANYA S GUHA looks at the alienation question of Northeast India

Tue, 03 Jun 2014

Reflections and dreams

ANANYA S GUHA urges to give free fictive imagination to one's dreams

Sat, 29 Mar 2014

Christmas and Me

ANANYA S GUHA gives a flavour of Christmas in Shillong

Sun, 22 Dec 2013

Paths and Stones

ANANYA S GUHA tries to sing a song of stones

Wed, 24 Jul 2013

A poem happens

ANANYA S GUHA on the birth of a poem

Thu, 13 Jun 2013

Fractured Mindset

Northeast India: Where does alienation stem from? The sub nationalism or nationalism that was at stake through the tortured histories of some of the states of Northeast India is the crux. This matrix has been lucidly evoked by Sudeep Chakravarti's book Highway 39 Journeys through a Fractured Land. Ananya S Guha probes into the causes which perpetuates an alienated mindset in the dialectics of mainland and outland.

Sun, 01 Jul 2012

Soccer in Shillong

ANANYA S GUHA reminisces over soccer-soaked Shillong days

Thu, 12 Jun 2014

Independence Day and Me

ANANYA S GUHA recollects memories of Independence Day celebrations in Shillong

Tue, 13 Aug 2013

A new thrust

The Thumb Print Conversations at the Shillong CALM Festival reiterated the need to obviate misconceptions of the region writes ANANYA S GUHA

Sun, 12 May 2013

Storm in CALM

The countdown for Shillong CALM Festival 2013 begins writes ANANYA S GUHA

Fri, 03 May 2013

Politics of Honesty

Even his worst adversaries admit that Tripura chief minister Manik Sarkar is an impeccably honest man, a rare breed among politicians today writes Ananya S Guha

Wed, 13 Mar 2013

The Sardar we know

ANANYA S GUHA analyses the recent debate over Sardar Patel

Fri, 01 Nov 2013

Liquid Ambience in Poetry

Mitali Chakravarty’s poems alternate between spirituality and the down to earth.

Sun, 28 Jul 2024

Ode to the hills and pines of Shillong

Poetry Column features Shillong poet Daniel Ebor Challam

Fri, 02 May 2025

Poems with a dangling question mark

Saikh Md. Sabah Al-Ahmed's poetry is embedded in pathos and lyricism

Mon, 26 May 2025

Poetic Vision of a Young Adult

A young poet covers themes from wars to other social injustices

Fri, 30 May 2025

Poems that explore love and injustice

Arunav Barua's poems tend to end with scepticism

Sat, 31 May 2025

Everyday Poems

Mollika Lahiri's poems evoke responses to regular happenings

Thu, 12 Jun 2025

Honeymoon murder reinforces stereotypes

Ananya S Guha feels that we can combat vitriol with quiet magnanimity

Tue, 17 Jun 2025

Of Christmas carols, cricket matches and cold winters

CHILDHOOD TALES: Ananya S Guha's childhood revolved around the seasons of Shillong

Sun, 29 Jun 2025

A Universal Poet

ThumbprintNE Poetry Column features young poet Shaheen Akhtar

Wed, 30 Jul 2025

Poetry as philosophical aphorisms

ThumbprintNE Poetry column features a sensitive poet, Jharna Choudhury

Wed, 06 Aug 2025

Rationality in Poetry

ThumbprintNE Poetry Column features Aman Verma

Sun, 17 Aug 2025

Poems with a rhythm

ThumbprintNE Poetry Column features young poet Gargisri Goswami

Mon, 25 Aug 2025

Symbolically Charged Poems

ThumbprintNE Poetry Column features an evocative poet Lalnunsanga Ralte

Wed, 29 Oct 2025

Nostalgia in Poetry

Poetry Column features evocative poet Mousumee Baruah

Wed, 03 Dec 2025

Thematic unity in poetry

Poetry Column features Mousumee Baruah

Wed, 03 Jun 2026

Rhyme and Rhythm

Poetry Column features Shillong-based poet Jasper Elias

Thu, 11 Jun 2026

Brevity of Wit

Poetry Column features Sutputra Radheye

Tue, 21 Jul 2026

An Elegiac Tone

Poetry Column features Shyamolima Saikia

Tue, 21 Jul 2026

When the young take to ideas

A poem by Ananya S Guha

Fri, 07 Aug 2026

When poetry intersect family life with politics

Poetry Column features Aditya Shankar

Tue, 25 Aug 2026

A Soft Personalised Cadence

Thumbprint Poetry Column features Maitrayee Deka

Mon, 26 Oct 2026