Columns

Rewriting history

ANANYA S GUHA looks at the alienation question of Northeast India

A lot of discussion is focused on North East India ranging from politics, the identity question, society and even literature. Seminars are held all over the country generating debate and polemics. The recent death of a young student from Arunachal Pradesh has raised the question of racist profiles. One view also challenges the singular view of North East India as one entity, considering factors of linguistic and religious divergence. Many of the seminars and conferences only result in producing books, which publishers from Delhi eyeing the academic market take advantage of. But what exactly is the problematic here is something which belies answer. Why do the people feel alienated? What is the periphery versus the ' mainstream '  question? Isn't the concept of mainstream disputatious, but for want of a better expression perhaps, it has gained currency.

First let us look at the alienation question. That this exists is indubitable, but why: this is something which must be answered, or looked into critically. Is it the racial factor, or racial differences and dichotomies, something which was prevalent in certain parts of South India in the 50s and 60s. M.J.Akbar in his lucid book, '' India: The Siege Within '' has pointed out with perspicuity how separatist tendencies, first began in South India, demolishing the myth that all talk of secessionist tendencies stated in North East India.
 
Secondly, is the sensitive issue that the people of North East India, especially the youth  are treated indifferently, or ' differently ' when they go to the ' mainland', resulting in a lot of protests in the recent past.
 
Thirdly is the predilection to treat the North East as a separate block and entity. This is tenable to a great extent because of border affinities and lack of development and connectivity. But a seminar in an air conditioned room in New Delhi is certainly no solution. I say it is true to a great extent, because at some social and political level the minds of the people meet, and they identify with one another out of empathy and look askance at New Delhi or the ' mainland '. This happens out of some experience or by negotiating with people outside their state, rude behavior or derogatory remarks.
 
Fourthly the carrot and stick policies of governments has created social disparities and divides. The classes have not been a result of a natural evolution, but has been thrust upon societies by sops and lure of money. This has also lead to corruptibility.
 
Fifthly is the sensitive question of identity, in the face of a threat of being overwhelmed or outnumbered by other communities, especially the migrant. I have always been saying that close knit communities evince such a threat because of small numbers, where there is behavioral pattern akin to a family. This must be comprehended or understand. This is certainly not necessarily parochialism. Parochialism exists in all communities of India, and the rubric of ' unity ' is tested time and again. This happens with reference to community, caste and religion. That India has withstood such pressures historically, is a grand testimony to its powers of absorption.
 
The solution if any, rests on subverting the mainland periphery myth. All regions are a part of the country, there is no mainstream or sub stream. In treating North East India as a singular identity we have to also comprehend its rich diversity and intra -  tribal communities. Not many know that the official language of Nagaland is English, and also one of the official languages of Meghalaya.The sense of alienation must be perceived as a problem of isolation and not that of parochialism. The people who have lived here for generations must identify with the major communities, and insist on their local identity as well. The identity question is one of allegiance and may not be racial in intent. In fact one person can have multiple identities in a clear headed manner. Also when people from outside the region come say on transfer, they must show a genuine interest in the cultures of the people rather than just waiting for their tenures to end. Cultural assimilation is the only solution to sectarian outbursts.Hurting people by making disparaging remarks about them or their communities can only hurt their feelings, and the sense of alienation festers. Wounds take a lot of time to heal... Community dispersion to other states of the country from this region, can also help not only in terms of economic sustenance, bt that of cultural exposure. I am sure the process has begun, and will accentuate in years to come. The current interest in North East Indian literature is a welcome sign, and many authors of thas region are winning plaudits for their literary talents, as well as in sports. The examples of Meghalaya and Manipur are sheer cases in point. 
 
History, let us hope will be re written.

Ananya.S. Guha25 Posts

used to work with the Indira Gandhi National Open University, Shillong (Meghalaya) as an Academic Administrator. He has over 30 years of teaching and administrative experience. He has six collections of poetry and his forms have been published world wide. Some of his poems are due to appear soon in an Anthology of Indian Poetry in English to be published by Harper Collins.

Sunset Years

ANANYA S GUHA sums up the discussion on “Old Age Homes” at the recently held Shillong CALM Festival 2013

Sun, 19 May 2013

The Calm of the CALM Festival

Picturesque Shillong gears up to celebrate creativity in the arts, music and literature writes Ananya S Guha

Mon, 22 Apr 2013

Fiction Online

Ananya S Guha writes about the eFiction Magazine, a literary online journal which blends tradition with modernity

Mon, 25 Mar 2013

Peace in Violence

Ananya S. Guha analyses the nuances of Northeast Indian Poetry

Tue, 28 Feb 2012

All for Land

The struggle for land seems to be the crux of all conflict in the region, writes Ananya S Guha

Wed, 01 Aug 2012

One Sohra Summer

Iadalang Pyngrope's book is a delightful blend of history and fiction writes ANANYA S GUHA

Tue, 20 May 2014

Poetry of Darius Cooper

ANANYA S GUHA traverses multiplicity of worlds in the poems of Darius Cooper

Wed, 07 May 2014

Mosaic

Iadalang Pyngrope's poems are experiential totality writes ANANYA S GUHA

Mon, 10 Mar 2014

Fable of the region

PETER W INGTY's book is a interesting exposition of certain historical truths writes ANANYA S GUHA

Fri, 17 Jan 2014

Tea Motif

NINA HARKNESS's novel straddles three decades in tea estates writes ANANYA S GUHA

Thu, 09 Jan 2014

Honour for Temsula Ao

ANANYA S GUHA chats with Sahitya Akademi award winning writer TEMSULA AO

Sun, 22 Dec 2013

Media Matters

ANANYA S GUHA ponders over the role of media in India

Mon, 14 Jul 2014

Rewriting history

ANANYA S GUHA looks at the alienation question of Northeast India

Tue, 03 Jun 2014

Reflections and dreams

ANANYA S GUHA urges to give free fictive imagination to one's dreams

Sat, 29 Mar 2014

Christmas and Me

ANANYA S GUHA gives a flavour of Christmas in Shillong

Sun, 22 Dec 2013

Paths and Stones

ANANYA S GUHA tries to sing a song of stones

Wed, 24 Jul 2013

A poem happens

ANANYA S GUHA on the birth of a poem

Thu, 13 Jun 2013

Fractured Mindset

Northeast India: Where does alienation stem from? The sub nationalism or nationalism that was at stake through the tortured histories of some of the states of Northeast India is the crux. This matrix has been lucidly evoked by Sudeep Chakravarti's book Highway 39 Journeys through a Fractured Land. Ananya S Guha probes into the causes which perpetuates an alienated mindset in the dialectics of mainland and outland.

Sun, 01 Jul 2012

Soccer in Shillong

ANANYA S GUHA reminisces over soccer-soaked Shillong days

Thu, 12 Jun 2014

Independence Day and Me

ANANYA S GUHA recollects memories of Independence Day celebrations in Shillong

Tue, 13 Aug 2013

A new thrust

The Thumb Print Conversations at the Shillong CALM Festival reiterated the need to obviate misconceptions of the region writes ANANYA S GUHA

Sun, 12 May 2013

Storm in CALM

The countdown for Shillong CALM Festival 2013 begins writes ANANYA S GUHA

Fri, 03 May 2013

Politics of Honesty

Even his worst adversaries admit that Tripura chief minister Manik Sarkar is an impeccably honest man, a rare breed among politicians today writes Ananya S Guha

Wed, 13 Mar 2013

The Sardar we know

ANANYA S GUHA analyses the recent debate over Sardar Patel

Fri, 01 Nov 2013

Liquid Ambience in Poetry

Mitali Chakravarty’s poems alternate between spirituality and the down to earth.

Sun, 28 Jul 2024